Where to Eat in Key Largo: A 2025 Guide to the Best Restaurants

The Florida Keys are a haven for travelers seeking sun-drenched beaches, vibrant coral reefs, and a laid-back tropical lifestyle. Key Largo, often referred to as the “Diving Capital of the World,” is not just a paradise for underwater enthusiasts but also a treasure trove for food lovers. Whether you’re craving freshly caught seafood, gourmet cuisine, or a casual meal with oceanfront views, Key Largo has something for every palate. This guide to where to eat in Key Largo in 2025 will highlight the best restaurants, their atmospheres, must-try menu items, and price ranges, ensuring your vacation is as delicious as it is memorable.

Where to Eat in Key Largo: Top Picks for Every Taste and Budget

Key Largo is home to a diverse culinary scene that reflects the region’s love for fresh, local ingredients. From elegant waterfront dining to quirky roadside cafes, the options are as plentiful as they are satisfying.

Snook’s Bayside Restaurant & Grand Tiki

Atmosphere: A lively waterfront destination featuring a grand tiki bar, live music, and breathtaking sunset views. The laid-back vibe makes it ideal for families and groups.

Menu Highlights: Creative seafood dishes, signature cocktails, and a variety of tropical-inspired appetizers.

Must-Try Items: Tuna Nachos, Lobster BLT, and their famous Key Lime Colada.

Address: 99470 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037

Cost: $$

Website: https://snooks.com/ 

Italian Food Company

Atmosphere: A cozy, modern eatery with rustic Italian charm. The Italian Food Company specializes in authentic, handmade Italian cuisine, offering a warm and inviting environment for any occasion.

Menu Highlights: Handmade pastas, wood-fired pizzas, and decadent desserts.

Must-Try Items: Burrata Salad, Truffle Pizza, and Tiramisu.

Address: 98070 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037

Cost: $$

Website: https://www.italianfoodcompany.com/ 

Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory

Atmosphere: A Key Largo institution for those with a sweet tooth, Blond Giraffe specializes in the Florida Keys’ iconic dessert: Key Lime Pie. The bright and cheery setting adds to its charm.

Menu Highlights: A variety of Key Lime Pie options, including frozen chocolate-dipped slices and gluten-free variations.

Must-Try Items: Classic Key Lime Pie and Frozen Key Lime Pie on a Stick.

Address: 99336 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037

Cost: $

Website: https://www.blondgiraffe.com/

Hobo’s Cafe

Atmosphere: Casual and cozy, Hobo’s Cafe is known for its relaxed vibe and generous portions. It’s the perfect spot for a laid-back lunch or dinner.

Menu Highlights: American favorites with a tropical twist, including seafood tacos and coconut shrimp.

Must-Try Items: Their Mahi Reuben, a creative take on the classic sandwich, is legendary.

Address: 101691 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037

Cost: $

Website: https://hoboscafe.net/menu/

Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen

Atmosphere: A Key Largo institution, Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen is famous for its quirky decor, friendly staff, and hearty comfort food.

Menu Highlights: Classic diner fare with a Florida Keys twist, featuring seafood, burgers, and award-winning Key Lime Pie.

Must-Try Items: The Lobster Mac & Cheese and Conch Fritters are local favorites.

Address: 99336 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037

Cost: $$

Website: https://mrsmacskitchen.com/

Best Places to Eat in Key Largo for Seafood Lovers

For those who want to savor the bounty of the sea, Key Largo’s seafood restaurants are unparalleled. Here are some of the best places to eat in Key Largo that will satisfy any seafood craving:

Sol by the Sea

Atmosphere: Set within the luxurious Playa Largo Resort, Sol by the Sea offers a charming seaside setting with bohemian-inspired decor and unbeatable ocean views. It’s perfect for a romantic dinner or special occasion.

Menu Highlights: A mix of fresh seafood and Caribbean-inspired dishes, complemented by craft cocktails and local brews.

Must-Try Items: Lobster Risotto, Crispy Whole Snapper, and the Signature Sunset Sangria.

Address: 97450 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037

Cost: $$$

Website: https://www.solbythesea.com/menus/#dinner

The Fish House

Atmosphere: Rustic and inviting, this quintessential Key Largo seafood restaurant exudes Old Florida charm. With nautical decor and friendly service, it’s a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Menu Highlights: Fresh-caught yellowtail snapper, cracked conch, and their famous Key Lime Pie.

Must-Try Items: The Matecumbe-style fish, topped with tomatoes, fresh basil, shallots, and capers, is a must.

Address: 102401 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037

Cost: $$

Website: https://fishhouse.com/

Ballyhoo’s Historic Seafood Grille

Atmosphere: Set in a charming old conch house, Ballyhoo’s offers a mix of history and flavor.

Menu Highlights: Sustainable seafood dishes, including stone crabs (in season) and tuna poke.

Must-Try Items: Don’t miss the All-You-Can-Eat Stone Crab Claws during stone crab season.

Address: 97860 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037

Cost: $$

Website: https://ballyhoosrestaurant.com/ 

Skipper’s Dockside

Atmosphere: A casual, family-friendly spot with stunning waterfront views and live music.

Menu Highlights: Fresh seafood prepared with a creative touch, along with a selection of tropical cocktails.

Must-Try Items: The Grouper Tacos and Shrimp & Grits are crowd-pleasers.

Address: 528 Caribbean Blvd, Key Largo, FL 33037

Cost: $$

Website: https://www.skippersdockside.com/

Hidden Gems: Restaurants in Key Largo You Can’t Miss

While the popular spots are fantastic, Key Largo is also home to hidden culinary gems that are worth seeking out.

Num Thai Restaurant & Sushi Bar

Atmosphere: A modest yet welcoming spot offering a surprising mix of Thai cuisine and sushi in the heart of Key Largo.

Menu Highlights: Fresh sushi rolls, flavorful curries, and traditional Thai appetizers.

Must-Try Items: The Key Largo Roll and Pad Thai are standout choices.

Address: 103200 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037

Cost: $$

Website: https://www.numthaiandsushi.com/ 

Best Places for Coffee or Eat Brunch in Key Largo

Wake up to the beautiful ocean views along the stunning island of Key Largo, and seek out a steaming cup of coffee or delicious brunch.  Here are some of the best places to eat in Key Largo for brunch or to find a great cup of coffee. 

Bayside Grille

Atmosphere: This waterfront spot is a hidden gem for a relaxed breakfast or brunch with stunning ocean views.

Menu Highlights: Classic breakfast favorites, fresh seafood options, and hearty omelets.

Must-Try Items: Crab Cake Benedict and the Tropical Fruit Pancakes.

Address: 99530 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037

Cost: $$

Website: https://baysidegrill.com/

Cafe Moka

Atmosphere: A cozy, European-style coffee shop with a welcoming ambiance and artisanal coffee.

Menu Highlights: Freshly brewed coffee, pastries, and light breakfast options.

Must-Try Items: The Coconut Latte and a buttery Croissant Sandwich.

Address: 91731 Overseas Hwy, Tavernier, FL 33070 (just south of Key Largo)

Cost: $

Website: https://www.facebook.com/p/Cafe-Moka-Florida-Keys-61558984073540/ 

Harriette’s Restaurant

Atmosphere: A local institution known for its down-home vibe and enormous muffins.

Menu Highlights: Traditional breakfast plates, omelets, and sweet treats.

Must-Try Items: Key Lime Muffins and their Biscuits & Gravy.

Address: 95710 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037

Cost: $

Website: https://www.harriettesrestaurant.com/

Green Turtle Inn

Atmosphere: A historic landmark offering a mix of classic and creative breakfast dishes.

Menu Highlights: Fresh seafood, hearty breakfast platters, and tropical mimosas.

Must-Try Items: Lobster Benedict and the French Toast with Guava Syrup.

Address: 81219 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036 (a short drive from Key Largo)

Cost: $$

Website: https://www.greenturtleinn.com/

Ocean Pointe Suites: The Perfect Base for Your Culinary Adventure

Exploring all the fantastic places to eat in Key Largo is made even better when you stay at Ocean Pointe Suites. This waterfront property offers spacious suites with fully equipped kitchens, stunning ocean views, and access to a private marina. Located conveniently near Key Largo’s best restaurants, Ocean Pointe Suites ensures you’re never far from your next great meal.

Why Choose Ocean Pointe Suites?

• Luxurious, condo-style accommodations with 1- and 2-bedroom options.
• Amenities include a private beach, oceanfront pool, tennis courts, and an on-site cafe.
• Ideal location close to popular dining spots and attractions in Key Largo.
• Family-friendly, with plenty of activities for all ages.

After indulging in the best dining experiences Key Largo has to offer, retreat to the comfort and elegance of Ocean Pointe Suites. Whether you’re starting your day with breakfast by the pool or winding down with a glass of wine on your private balcony, your stay here will elevate your Key Largo vacation to new heights.

Plan Your Key Largo Getaway Today

From upscale waterfront dining to quirky local favorites, Key Largo offers an unforgettable culinary journey for every visitor. Whether you’re a seafood lover, an adventurous eater, or someone who enjoys a simple, hearty meal, the restaurants in Key Largo have you covered.

Make your vacation even more special by booking your stay at Ocean Pointe Suites. With its luxurious accommodations, prime location, and easy access to the best places to eat in Key Largo, Ocean Pointe Suites is the ultimate home base for your 2025 Florida Keys adventure.

Book your stay today and savor the flavors of Key Largo!