Hidden Eateries of Treasure Island: Discovering Local Favorites
Treasure Island, Florida, is a paradise for food lovers seeking to experience authentic, local cuisine. Tucked away from the main tourist paths, the hidden eateries of Treasure Island offer a delightful array of flavors, from fresh seafood to mouth-watering barbecues. This guide will introduce you to the best local places to eat in Treasure Island, ensuring you savor every bite during your visit.
Local Favorites: Best Foods to Eat in Treasure Island
1. Middle Grounds Grill
Address: 10925 Gulf Blvd, Treasure Island, FL 33706
Most Popular Dishes: Grouper Oscar, Shrimp and Scallop Scampi
Notable Menu Item: Lobster Bisque
Middle Grounds Grill is a local favorite known for its elegant ambiance and superb seafood. The Grouper Oscar, a dish featuring fresh grouper topped with crab meat and hollandaise sauce, is a must-try. The Shrimp and Scallop Scampi, cooked to perfection with garlic butter and white wine, will leave your taste buds yearning for more. Don’t miss out on the rich, creamy Lobster Bisque, a staple that defines the restaurant’s excellence.
2. Foxy’s Café
Address: 160 107th Ave, Treasure Island, FL 33706
Most Popular Dishes: Foxy’s Famous Reuben, Grouper Sandwich
Notable Menu Item: Clam Chowder
Foxy’s Café offers a casual dining experience with a cozy atmosphere. Known for their Reuben sandwich, which features perfectly grilled corned beef, Swiss cheese, and sauerkraut on rye bread, Foxy’s attracts both locals and tourists alike. The Grouper Sandwich, fresh and flavorful, is another highlight. Pair these with a bowl of their renowned Clam Chowder, and you’ll understand why Foxy’s is among the best local places to eat in Treasure Island.
3. The Floridian
Address: 230 107th Ave, Treasure Island, FL 33706
Most Popular Dishes: Cuban Sandwich, Mojo Pork
Notable Menu Item: Empanadas
For a taste of authentic Cuban cuisine, The Floridian is an essential stop. Their Cuban Sandwich, with layers of ham, roast pork, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard pressed between Cuban bread, is legendary. The Mojo Pork, marinated and slow-roasted to perfection, offers a burst of flavors. Don’t forget to try their Empanadas, crispy on the outside and filled with savory goodness.
Where to Find Local Favorites: Hidden Eateries of Treasure Island
4. Sea Dog Brewing Co.
Address: 9610 Gulf Blvd, Treasure Island, FL 33706
Most Popular Dishes: Lobster Mac & Cheese, Fish Tacos
Notable Menu Item: Pretzel Sticks with Beer Cheese
Sea Dog Brewing Co. is not just about great beer; it’s also about amazing food. The Lobster Mac & Cheese, made with tender lobster meat and creamy cheese sauce, is a standout dish. Their Fish Tacos, packed with fresh, flavorful ingredients, are a crowd-pleaser. For a perfect pairing with their craft beers, try the Pretzel Sticks served with a delicious beer cheese dip.
5. Sloppy Joe’s Treasure Island
Address: 10650 Gulf Blvd, Treasure Island, FL 33706
Most Popular Dishes: Joe’s Famous Sloppy Joe, Blackened Mahi Sandwich
Notable Menu Item: Key Lime Pie
Sloppy Joe’s offers a lively beachside dining experience. Their signature dish, Joe’s Famous Sloppy Joe, is a savory, messy delight. The Blackened Mahi Sandwich, featuring fresh mahi-mahi seasoned and grilled to perfection, is another favorite. Finish your meal with their Key Lime Pie, a sweet and tangy dessert that perfectly captures the essence of Florida.
6. Caddy’s Treasure Island
Address: 9000 W Gulf Blvd, Treasure Island, FL 33706
Most Popular Dishes: Mahi Tacos, Grouper Reuben
Notable Menu Item: Crab Cakes
Caddy’s is the go-to spot for beachside dining with a view. The Mahi Tacos, filled with fresh mahi-mahi and a zesty slaw, are a top pick. Their Grouper Reuben, a unique twist on the classic sandwich, is a must-try. The Crab Cakes, loaded with fresh crab meat and served with a tangy remoulade, are another standout item that makes Caddy’s a hidden gem among the eateries of Treasure Island.
7. Ka’Tiki
Address: 8803 W Gulf Blvd, Treasure Island, FL 33706
Most Popular Dishes: Cheeseburger, Fish and Chips
Notable Menu Item: Buffalo Shrimp
Ka’Tiki is known for its laid-back vibe and great food. The Cheeseburger, juicy and cooked to perfection, is a local favorite. The Fish and Chips, featuring crispy fried fish and golden fries, is another popular choice. For something a bit different, try their Buffalo Shrimp, which offers a spicy kick and is perfect for sharing.
8. Shrimpys Blues Bistro
Address: 9524 Blind Pass Rd, St Pete Beach, FL 33706
Most Popular Dishes: Jambalaya, Shrimp and Grits
Notable Menu Item: Crawfish Étouffée
Just a short drive from Treasure Island, Shrimpys Blues Bistro serves up flavorful Cajun and Creole dishes. The Jambalaya, packed with shrimp, chicken, and sausage, is a hearty, satisfying meal. The Shrimp and Grits, with its creamy grits and perfectly cooked shrimp, is another favorite. For an authentic taste of Louisiana, try the Crawfish Étouffée, rich and spicy with tender crawfish tails.
Hidden Eateries of Treasure Island
9. VIP Mexican American Cuisine
Address: 10625 Gulf Blvd, Treasure Island, FL 33706
Most Popular Dishes: VIP Burrito, Fish Tacos
Notable Menu Item: Churros
VIP Mexican American Cuisine offers a vibrant dining experience with a fusion of Mexican and American flavors. The VIP Burrito, filled with your choice of meat, beans, rice, and cheese, is a substantial and delicious option. The Fish Tacos, fresh and flavorful, are another top pick. End your meal with their Churros, crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, served with a side of chocolate sauce for dipping.
10. The Pearl Restaurant
Address: 163 107th Ave, Treasure Island, FL 33706
Most Popular Dishes: Stuffed Lobster Tail, Beef Wellington
Notable Menu Item: French Onion Soup
For a fine dining experience, The Pearl Restaurant is an excellent choice. The Stuffed Lobster Tail, filled with crabmeat and drizzled with lemon butter, is an exquisite dish. The Beef Wellington, with its tender beef and flaky pastry, is a culinary delight. Start your meal with their French Onion Soup, a rich and savory classic that sets the tone for a memorable dining experience.
11. Waffle House Treasure Island
Address: 111 108th Ave, Treasure Island, FL 33706
Most Popular Dishes: All-Star Special, Hashbrowns
Notable Menu Item: Pecan Waffles
For a comforting and casual breakfast or brunch, Waffle House is a beloved spot. The All-Star Special, which includes eggs, bacon or sausage, toast, and hashbrowns, is a hearty way to start your day. The Hashbrowns, cooked to golden perfection, are a must-try. And, of course, their Pecan Waffles, light and fluffy with a nutty crunch, are an essential part of the Waffle House experience.
Stay at Oceana Beachfront Suites
After indulging in the culinary delights of Treasure Island, from vegetarian meals to beach bars, you’ll need a comfortable and luxurious place to relax. Oceana Beachfront Suites offers just that with its modern amenities and stunning ocean views. The resort features spacious suites with fully equipped kitchens, private balconies, and plush bedding. Guests can enjoy the beachfront pool, fitness center, and complimentary Wi-Fi. Located just steps from the beach, Oceana Beachfront Suites is the perfect place to unwind after a day of exploring the hidden eateries of Treasure Island. Book your stay at Oceana Beachfront Suites and experience the ultimate in comfort and convenience during your Treasure Island getaway.
Exploring the hidden eateries of Treasure Island, FL, will surely be a highlight of your trip. From savory seafood to spicy Cajun dishes, these local favorites offer a diverse range of flavors that will leave you wanting more. So, pack your bags and get ready to discover the best local places to eat in Treasure Island, where every meal is an adventure.
previous story