A Foodie's Guide: 10 Must-Try Restaurants in Treasure Island

Where to Eat in Treasure Island, Florida

Nestled on Florida's West Coast is Treasure Island, a haven for culinary aficionados. With its pristine beaches, Treasure Island offers a unique blend of traditional flavors and innovative cuisines. This melting pot of gastronomic wonders reflects the region's rich history and the influence of various cultures. From beachside shacks serving the freshest seafood to upscale bistros presenting gourmet dishes, there's something for every palate. 

 

What's Good to Eat in Treasure Island, Florida?

Treasure Island is not just about beaches and sunsets; it's a culinary hub with an array of dining options. This town brings together the best of both worlds – from traditional Florida dishes inspired by the rich marine life of the Gulf of Mexico to international flavors. The presence of waterfront restaurants lets you indulge in two of life's great pleasures simultaneously: delicious food and mesmerizing views.

A Foodies’ Destination: Treasure Island

Check out the bustling John's Pass Village and Boardwalk, a retail and dining hotspot that's an epicenter for fresh seafood and boutique eateries. For those who are interested in exploring local produce, the Sunday Morning Market is a must-visit, showcasing local farmers and artisans.

10 Must-Try Restaurants in Treasure Island, Florida

1. The Pearl Restaurant

Best known for: A romantic waterfront view and gourmet dishes. Reservations recommended.

Cuisine: Seafood and steaks.

Must-try: Their signature Lobster Thermidor.

Address: 163 107th Ave, Treasure Island, FL 33706

Website: https://www.thepearlfinedining.com/

2. The Boardwalk Grill

Best known for: Alfresco dining overlooking the beach.

Cuisine: Casual beach fare.

Must-try: Grilled Mahi-Mahi sandwich with a side of sweet potato fries.

Address: 204 Johns Pass Boardwalk W, Madeira Beach, just a hop from Treasure Island.

Webpage: The Boardwalk Grill 

3. Gigi's Italian Restaurant

Best known for: Its rustic charm and old-world recipes, and crusty, brick oven pizza.

Cuisine: Italian.

Must-try: Homemade Fettuccine Alfredo.

Address: 105 Treasure Isle Causeway, Treasure Island, FL 33706

Website: Gigi's Italian Restaurant

4. Ricky T's Bar & Grille

Best known for: Nightly entertainment and eclectic menu.

Cuisine: American with a twist.

Must-try: Ricky's Famous Crab Cakes.

Address: 10601 Gulf Blvd, Treasure Island, FL 33706

Website: http://www.rickytsbarandgrille.com/

5. Shrimpy's Blues Bistro

Best known for: Live jazz nights complemented by a seafood-centric menu.

Cuisine: Seafood and Southern comfort.

Must-try: New Orleans-style Shrimp and Grits.

Address: 9524 Blind Pass Rd, St. Pete Beach, close to Treasure Island.

Website: shrimpysbluesbistro.com

6. Middle Grounds Grill

Best known for: Elegant dining with a beachy feel.

Cuisine: International seafood.

Must-try: Chilean Sea Bass served with risotto.

Address: 10925 Gulf Blvd, Treasure Island, FL 33706

Website: https://www.middlegroundsgrill.com/

7. Foxy's Café

Best known for: Generous portions and a family-friendly vibe.

Cuisine: Classic American.

Must-try: The Big Breakfast Burrito.

Address: 160 107th Ave, Treasure Island, FL 33706

Website: Foxy Cafe

8. Caddy's Treasure Island

Best known for: Tropical drinks and beach lounging.

Cuisine: Beach bites and cocktails.

Must-try: The Caddy's Coconut Shrimp.

Address: 9000 W Gulf Blvd, Treasure Island, FL 33706

Website: https://caddys.com/caddys-treasure-island/

9. Britt's Coal Fire Pizza

Best known for: Relaxed ambiance with authentic coal-fired pizzas.

Cuisine: Italian-inspired.

Must-try: The Treasure Island Special Pizza.

Address: 10709 Gulf Blvd, Treasure Island, FL 33706

Website: https://www.brittspizza.com/

10. VIP Mexican Restaurant & Lounge

Best known for: A fusion of traditional and contemporary Mexican dishes.

Cuisine: Mexican.

Must-try: Enchiladas Suizas.

Address: 10625 Gulf Blvd, Treasure Island, FL 33706

Website: http://www.viplounge-fla.com/

Where's the Best Beachfront Place to Eat in Treasure Island, Florida?

Nestled among these culinary gems is the Sunset Vistas Beachfront Suites, offering not just an exquisite stay but, also a delightful dining experience. The resort's in-house Cafe Beach Bar offers an array of sumptuous dishes, close by your home away from home while on vacation.

Best Known For:  Beachfront location offers an unparalleled dining experience

Cuisine: A blend of local flavors

Must Try: Tropical Island Chicken Sandwich and its signature Sunset Vistas Punch

It's a gastronomic journey in itself. With its blend of flavors, refreshing beverages, and the captivating view of the Gulf, it's a destination every foodie should mark on their Treasure Island map.